Thursday, June 12, 2014

A Doctor's Point of View: Report 2014 FIENS (Foundation for International Education in Neurological Surgery)


FIENS Report
Muhimbili Orthopedic Institute
Dar es Salaam, Tanzania

May 26 – June 6, 2014

David Pitkethly, MD FACS

 

   The Neurosurgery Department in Dar es Salaam is located at the Muhimbili Orthopedic Institute (MOI). The name, of course, is misleading because this hospital includes neurosurgery as well as orthopedics. The MOI bed count is stated as 450, but in actuality it is many more because a large percentage of patients are relegated to mattresses in hallways and between beds. On the pediatric wards there are two and sometimes three patients per bed. A new large seven story hospital is nearing completion adjacent to the existing hospital. The new facility will be a modern hospital with new operating rooms, emergency room, CT, MRI, CyberKnife, fully equipped ICU, Telemedicine, as well as patient beds. To complete the picture of MOI it should be understood that it is a small part of a huge campus that also includes additional hospitals for all medical specialties with a total of 1500 beds, medical school, dental school and nursing school.

   The Neurosurgery Department is ably chaired by Professor Joseph Kahamba, who trained in Zurich, Switzerland. He has a full schedule of surgical procedures, clinics, conferences and administrative duties. His leadership and clinical skills are excellent. There are four other fully residency trained faculty members. One trained in Japan and the others in South Africa. There are presently six other physicians in neurosurgery residency programs outside Tanzania. Several pre-resident registrars work up new admissions, follow patients on the wards, and assist in the OR.

   The daily schedule begins at 0730 in the Conference Room with presentations by registrars and medical students of new admissions (mostly trauma cases) for both neurosurgery and orthopedic services. After cases are discussed there is usually 30 minutes remaining for other medical topics. On two mornings I gave lectures at the conference. The topics were “Chiari 1 Malformation” and “Cervical Radicular Syndromes”.

   At 0900 the faculty members as well as registrars attend clinics or operating “theater”. On Thursday one of the junior faculty, with every available registrar and medical student on the service, conducts formal patient teaching rounds.  This is a 3+ hour exhausting process with about 80 – 100 patients being seen. The beds are in large open wards with about ½ of the patients occupying mattresses in hallways and between beds. We were constantly stepping over and sometimes on these mattresses as our group of a 12-16 doctors, students and nurses made our way through these rounds. The unfortunate reality is that many of the patients have been waiting for weeks and months to have needed surgery. I counted five children and young adults with huge craniopharyngiomas, blindness and large ventricles. The pediatric ward had at least fifteen children needing surgery for hydrocephalus and/or meningomyeloceles. The problem is that there are only five operating rooms in the hospital for elective surgery, and neurosurgery has only one dedicated room. Orthopedics, which has dominated this hospital, has the other four rooms. On one day a week neurosurgery has two rooms. Perhaps, when the new hospital opens in a few months, this situation will be ameliorated.

   Operating rooms are scheduled to begin at 9 am and finish at 3 pm. This translates to one craniotomy, two laminectomies, or three hydrocephalus operations per operating day. Another OR problem is a lack of working equipment. For example, there are power drills in the storeroom, but none of them work, either for lack of parts or poor maintenance. There is no gas sterilization and it appears that some of the drills have been autoclaved. All craniotomies are done with the Hudson brace and bits, and Gigli saws. There is a good working microscope with observer scope and small screen monitor.

     During my two weeks at the MOI I was in the operating room almost every day as first assistant. We did a variety of benign brain tumors, three spine operations for degenerative disc disease, and one ACoA aneurysm. I assisted on two extremely vascular meningiomas. Neither angiography nor embolization are available at MOI, and after two units of blood had been transfused in each case, the anesthesiologist called a halt to the operation. The patients were subsequently transferred to Apollo Hospitals in India under an agreement for funding between those hospitals and the Tanzanian government.

    I did not see any gliomas on the wards or in the OR during my stay. I discussed this with Prof. Kahamba and he responded that meningiomas are much more common than gliomas in Tanzania.  

   One of the neurosurgeons, Hamisi Shabani, completed the hydrocephalus training program with the Ben Warf group in Uganda. He received funding and has a complete setup with flexible endoscope to perform third ventriculostomies. He now does ETVs with coagulation of the choroid plexus bilaterally on all of his hydrocephalus patients. He is sending his data to Uganda to be included in the Warf study.

   Despite these challenges, the neurosurgeons as a whole are well trained, competent, and take good care of their patients. Professor Kahamba and others are in negotiations to begin a neurosurgery residency program at MOI. As mentioned above, the new hospital will have an MR scanner, endovascular services, modern ICU beds with monitoring, and technologically advanced equipment that will bring their department to a level of a European or American teaching hospital in a few years.

   There is no housing available on campus for visiting physicians. I found a terrific small hotel, The Swiss Garden, that is an easy walk of less than a mile from the hospital. The price was $120 per night which included an excellent breakfast. The only problem was that they do not accept payment by any means other than cash. If anyone chooses this hotel it is best to pay in advance.

   The weekend we were in Dar es Salaam my wife and I boarded one of the fast ferries to Zanzibar on Saturday morning and returned Sunday afternoon. We stayed at the Tembo House Hotel in Stone Town which had been the US Consulate during colonial days and the cost was $135. The hotel is beautifully preserved with many antiques, and has a perfect central location on the beach. Zanzibar is an idyllic island and I highly recommend a visit.

   The weather was somewhat hot and humid, but not uncomfortable. We had no rain and the rainy season should be avoided. Slacks and open collar short sleeved shirts are appropriate dress for all occasions.

   The overall experience in Tanzania and the Muhimbili Orthopedic Institute was outstanding, and I highly recommend it to interested neurosurgeon volunteers.

David Pitkethly, MD
Professor Emeritus
Department of Neurosurgery
University of Washington

Our Tanzanian Adventure


A Weekend in Kabongo

 


Kelvin and Moses in their new American "going-to-church" suits
Our four little fishies at play
  Before starting our work in Tanzania, it was time for FUN! David and I had planned our trip so that we could spend our first weekend in Eldoret, Kenya. This is the lovely small city where we had volunteered in 2012, and I had found Veronicah, an orphan. You may recall from my earlier blogs, that we had enrolled her and her 3 siblings in private school, arranged to have them tutored in English, signed them up for Scouts and swimming and have continued to mentor them from afar. Due to hardship at their Grandmother's home, we enrolled the older 3 in the Patrician School as boarders last year, which they love. Unfortunately, Moses is not eligible until grade 5. We call and write them every month, and they write us back. It had been one year since we had last seen them, and I was SO excited! We brought a large suitcase filled with clothes, books, games, puzzles, crayons etc. and we rented a duplex at the Eldoret Club, so we could all stay close.
Our charming duplex at the Eldoret Club
And what a delight to all be together again! Lean, long and lovely, Sharon had again grown taller and even more poised. Kelvin was just at that pubertal threshold, not yet into his growth spurt and, even though he wasn’t much taller than Moses, he had definitely lost that “little kid” look. Veronicah was the fun, exuberant one who came running from the pack, wanting to be the first for hugs. And Moses was still a little boy with a wide easy grin and bubbling enthusiasm.


Our lean and lovely Sharon


Time to test out those new running shoes
     Our first stop was the Patrician School to confer with Teachers Sammy and Jim and check out the scholastics. Their teachers report they are all trying hard but due to their minimal previous schooling, it is a challenge for them to function at grade level. They love school and truly want to do better and I think as their English continues to improve, so will their academic performance. We have set high goals for them, reminding them that with good grades they can attend the University. We’ll see them through as far as they wish. However, if higher education is not in their future, we will be certain to find a vocational school that will teach them skills for independent living. Sharon is almost 15 years old, Kelvin 13, Veronicah turns 14 in 
Veronicah, high and mighty and strong
December, and Moses will be 10 that same month. Sharon and Kelvin are both in 6th grade, Veronicah in 5th and Moses in 1st. They live in a small mud house in nearby Kabongo with their Grandma and Grandpa, less than 1km. from the school. The 3 boarders live at home when school is not in session.We asked Grandma to join us as the teachers discussed their grades. We all must work as a team to keep these kids advancing in the right direction.

      After a quick trip into town (their second time in a supermarket, the first was with us in 2012) for English dictionaries and ice cream, it was time to hit the pool. Then we did some painting and crafts that I had brought along, and watched the movie “Ice Age” on our laptop.  One of the true highlights for them was to take a hot bath, which they had never had before. Grandma's has no water or sanitation or electricity, and the school provides only cold water for showers. You can imagine their excitement to lay down and soak! (Next year I’ll bring bubble bath!!).
   We had ascertained their foot size and had brought along a new pair of running shoes for everyone, even Grandma. David organized a 4 km. “fun-run” for all on Sunday morning. At noon a buffet lunch was served at the Club and these kids had never seen so much food. They piled their plates high with a generous portion from every serving platter and ate every morsel. It was all I could do to keep from cringing when Moses sat down next to me and starting happily crunching fish heads, a favorite treat. Oh my-


Saying goodby: Sharon, Moses, Kelvin, Grandma Jane, Veronicah.
 Many thanks to family and friends who help us support this deserving family.
 Your donations really make a differences.
 
     Our dear friends Brother Paul, and Dr. Hilary Mabeya, the “fistula surgeon”, and his wife Carolyne, who is our "guardian" for this family, joined us later for dinner. The weekend seemed to finish so soon and we sadly said goodbye for another year. Thanks to email, we’ll all keep in touch. Monday morning we flew on to Dar es Salaam in Tanzania.



 

Arrival In Dar es Salaam

 

    It was a short flight from Eldoret to Dar but the 11 hour time change was taking its toll. When we finally arrived in Dar, we were 2 weary and disheveled travelers. We were met at the airport by Tara, a youthfully exuberant critical care nurse practitioner who had worked for many years in Charleston, South Carolina. She had longed for a chance to be involved in global medicine and volunteered for a 2 year stint in Dar, working at the Mohimbili Orthopedic/Neurological Institute (MOI). She was a raz-matazzy font of endless knowledge about the city, the hospital, the personnel, the schedules and even our cell phones. We were fortunate to receive her attention for the first several days before she moved on to her next role of mother-hen to 2 Clemson engineering students. These friendly fellows were on a semester abroad program and had come “to fix broken equipment in the operating room”, which, in effect was almost everything!



Operating room shoes. Pick a pair! Any pair!
     David had searched the internet and had found us a small hotel hear the hospital. The Swiss Garden Hotel is probably one of the most charming places we have ever stayed. Towered over by large new 30 story apartment/condo buildings on all sides, this little treasure features small wooden bungalows with private canopied verandas, hot water and air conditioning. Lush gardens surrounded us on our winding path to the lobby and outdoor thatched dining area.
Our  delightful Swiss Garden bungalow


David presents our $15,000 donations to Dr. Mugisha, and Tara
    Once we got over our initial jet-lag our days started to take on a new rhythm. Morning neurosurgical conference began at 7:30 (that is, 7:45, African time), which we attended together, followed by review of the day’s surgical cases and ICU rounds. After this David and I parted ways and I followed my own schedule. One day I attended a mother-baby shunt clinic for infants born with hydrocephalus (a not uncommon birth defect within the brain, causing the baby to develop a very large head filled with cerebral spinal fluid.  Without surgical intervention at an early age, it is most likely to end in death. It is preventable with pre-natal folate, but poor young African women rarely see a doctor until after birthing). Another time I dropped by the mortuary to watch cadaver work as visiting plastic surgeons from L.A. taught young Tanzanian physicians new techniques, though certainly not of the face-lift variety. This workshop was to repair terrible facial disfigurement secondary to highway injuries or falls.

!6 year old unmarried mom from the country seen for the first time in clinic. Her 6 month old baby has a myelomeningocele and is paralyzed from the waist down. Surgery should have been done in the first 24h. after birth to close the opening in the skin. The paralysis will remain.
Hydrocephalus Workshop. Very few chairs. At the end of the class I gave each
young mom a small "frog" flashlight that was donated by Sun Company of Colorado. (Thank you!)



 
 
Muhimbili


 The Muhimbili campus is very large, probably close to 1 square mile with buildings of varying ages (and stages of decay), many of the 1950’s-60's vintage while others clearly new and modern. It is comprised of many individual centers such as the medical school, dental and nursing schools, housing, maternity wing for high-risk pregnancies, a Rotary pediatric oncology clinic, AIDS clinic and many more. It is also a surging mass of wandering patients and their families, asking for help or waiting for care. The only area around the buildings where grass can grow is where it has been fenced off, often with barbed wire. Otherwise, a family grouping will have claimed that turf for waiting, eating, sleeping, changing, washing clothes etc.

    One low building had been divided down the middle by a long wall with a door on each side of the divider. It was a chapel for Catholics on the left, and for Anglicans &

The  'bi-chapel"
Lutherans on the right. What drew my attention were the loud exhortations and the “fire and brimstone” fist-pounding rhetoric of a funeral service being held on the right side. Despite an open casket on wheels, draped in white linen and covered with red roses, the minister felt no need to send this soul “gently into the dark night” but rather, used his demise as a reminder that the time to repent is now! Mohimbili has everything!

  While some buildings were packed with patients scrunched together on the few available benches, leaning against the walls or sitting on the floor as they wait for care, many other buildings, often 3- 4 stories high had unused offices and meetings rooms. The old wooden desks are empty, the walls are bare and defaced and a lone receptionist at the front entry chats with the ubiquitous security guard. As I explore the many departments, often without David, I am seen as a visiting white woman of the medical sort and have easy access to anywhere I wish to go.  If I am stopped, it is only to inquire how I can be helped.  I talk freely to the patients, to doctors, to families and all are delighted to be acknowledged and be photographed.

     The wards of the combined neuro/ortho hospital consist of a large open room with 25-40 beds all very close together. Bed count, however is not an accurate patient count since many patients lay on mattresses on the floor as well. Families handle most of the patients needs such as bathing,
 

changing and washing linens, providing food and feeding. Upon admission, the physician will write down the required medicine needed, and the family will buy it and bring it in (morphine, opioids and the rare use of insulin are the exception). Patients take very few medicines, they can’t afford to buy them. The nurses say they work hard, but to my assessment, they do very little. This laid-back relaxed African style is similar to what we had experienced in Kenya and Ethiopia. All hospital staff, that is, cleaning people, doctors, security guards, nurses etc. seem to “hang out”/schmooze a lot. They’ll wander in and out of different areas, they’ll meander outside, chat with friends, laugh and share pleasantries before slowly migrating back to their work area, only to repeat the process a short time later. “Hakuna matata” is a common phrase they frequently say with a gentle smile. It means “no problem”, and despite dry IV’s, soiled dressings and minimal handwashing, all is taken in stride.

 

Doctors Rounds

 

   
Rounds are made by doctors and nurses (often 15-18 people total).
Note the mosquito netting that hangs over every bed
 Rounds take a very long time. Neurosurgeons lead the once weekly grand rounds and David saw close to 100 patients over 3 hours. The residents (“registrars”) and medical students round on these patients the remaining 6 days, when they can. This being said, however, it is essential to understand that since the

This young girl has a brain tumor
 (craniopharyngioma) and is blind in one eye.
Hopefully she will have surgery soon.
“standard of care” is on an entirely different level, the competence, relative to this standard is still adequate. Patients only get what they can afford. Most can manage the cost of an x-ray ($8) but  only those with insurance get CT scans ($50), and MRI's ($200). Often there is little alternative except to “wait and see”. The good news is that many patients slowly improve on their own. There’s no feeling of intensity to do more. During rounds, doctors rarely converse with the patients, and the patients do not ask any questions nor seem too concerned, even when they appear quite ill. The nurses follow the doctors on their rounds, creating a large crowd in white as they all inch their way along from bed to bed. Charts and films are kept in a large brown folder on the patient's beds. Doctors do not carry stethoscopes and rarely touch the patient or look under dressings, probably due to the fact that there are few sinks and even fewer working hand dispensers. Residents and medical students often wear lab coats provided by drug companies as evidenced by the large logo and brand name of their most popular drugs embroidered on the breast pocket in large letters (just to serve as a reminder).



In making rounds, doctors and staff must sometimes step on
mattresses. Patients often stay for months to hold their place in line for surgery.
 

We saw many, many nasty looking open extremity fractures and there is a very serious problem with infection. However, since cultures are too expensive to process, patients are regularly treated with broad-spectrum antibiotics, a “hit-or-miss” approach. The doctors we met had been trained abroad (Japan, Norway, South Africa) and are capable of doing more for their patients but since many supplies, instrumentation and treatment modalities are unobtainable, they are resigned and acknowledge they can only "work with what we've got". They are keenly aware that their medical system will not change until the priorities of their government changes. They accept this with a good natured cheerfulness. despite the profound and glaring inadequacies that they face every day.

 

 

A Gastronomic Desert  (no, not "dessert"...)

 


Hospital cafeteria kitchen at lunch time
   Tanzanians are great meat-eaters, relying on sausages, fish heads, tough beef kabobs and roasted (scrawny) chicken parts. When served with rice and chopped greens of various varieties, their meal is complete. One of their everyday favorites is ugali, a cross between corn-meal mush and mashed potatoes. It is served in immense snowball size portions and when kneaded between the fingers, it serves as a pick-up/dunking/smooshing tool, eliminating the need for silverware. Another very popular all-day item is "chips majai", essentially, a pile of French fries cooked in an omelet. I guess it could equate to hash browns and scrambled eggs at Denny's, Tanzanian style.

   Our only real complaint about the food was: where do we find it?? A small eatery (“cafeteria” would certainly be a euphemism) with “hot bar” of assorted items was set up outside the front door of the hospital, and locals cooked during the late morning and early afternoon. For those who might eat later, the only offerings were  leftovers that had already been found most attractive to the endless hordes of flies. The Tanzanians don’t appear to eat their evening meal outside the home, hence, there are very few restaurants. One local restaurant called “Delicious Food” was already closed at 6PM when we stopped by. The young woman there said “no food”. Could she recommend a place nearby? “No, no restaurant”. Unfortunately, she was correct. Most restaurants are in the large hotels and cater to foreigners but the MOI Hospital, being a public hospital, is not near any tourist areas. Our Swiss Garden Hotel offered an evening meal but the choice was limited to one curry dish served daily. Our wizard friend Tara came to our rescue and sent us off to a hole-in the-wall called “Texas Grill” that 
Texas Grill. All finger food, but isn't everything here?!
made the best bbq chicken and fresh  garlic naan we can ever remember having. We stocked our hotel room with freshly roasted cashews, salty cassava chips and ripe bananas; after all, we hadn't come to Tanzania for the food.

 



Zanzibar!

 Exoticus Ultimus Maximus! What other thought could such a name conjure up?!… and I was not proved wrong. We had an open weekend and were ready to go!  For $40 a ticket we traveled first class on a large capacity catamaran for the 2 hour sail to Stone Town. Disembarking was a nightmare, the moment one is off the gangplank, the jostling and heckling starts by the “touts” who far outnumber their hapless prey. 
Dar, as seen from our catamaran
They are not rude, merely insistent on selling you, showing you, telling you that they have just what you need (Hotel? Taxi? Tour? Snacks? Postcards?) and they are reluctant to be dismissed. I am not too proud to admit that we were eventually ensnared and taken, by a longer route than necessary, to The Tembo House (Swahili for “elephant”). This magnificent waterfront hotel was originally the US Consulate and had been renovated into 26 rooms with private bath ($125). Our 3rd floor shuttered windows indulged us with breath-taking views of fishing boats, swimmers in
the Indian Ocean, the hustle-bustle of beach life and golden-orange sunsets.

Our spectacular waterfront room
Lunch at our hotel by the Indian Ocean

  Our guidebook recommended to ignore restaurants for dinner and instead, go to the beach front in the center of town, where a nightly array of perhaps 40 local “chefs” cook up skewers of succulent meat, lobster, shrimp, crab, on small charcoal grills. It is served with your choice of a yeasty coconut bread (yes!), chapati (Tanzanian flatbread) or toasted pita. It has a carnival/food circus atmosphere that enlivens all of your senses as you watch and hear and smell the sizzle of your fresh-from-the-ocean dinner being prepared. It was easy to find seating near the water on the large open benches and I was soon surrounded by a patient orchestra of street kitties, waiting for tumbling tasty morsels (they were rightfully indulged). We finished off our repast with freshly squeezed tamarind juice and a grilled crepe with sliced banana, mango and Nutella which was then drizzled with chocolate! It was an evening to remember!

Fresh seafood skewers

  We set out the next morning for a look around Stone Town. Our first stop was a visit to the Old Fort from 1700 where Arabs defended attacks by the Portuguese. Much of the fort still remains and is now home to a dozen souvenir shops. Close by was the Palace, built in the 1890’s for the Sultans, their families and harams (Sultan rule ended in 1964 with a revolution). Much of the original furniture, porcelain and paintings is still in place and provides a fascinating glimpse into an earlier era.

  We braved the endless stream of foot traffic to explore the vast maze of tiny, narrow lanes of the street markets. Large groups of Muslim women shopped for brightly jeweled dresses to wear beneath their black hijab and “days of the week” 
"Days of the week" panties,
ready for Muslim ladies fannies
panties in hot pink and lace mounded in 3 foot high piles on the ground, were also a popular item. All essentials can be found in these stalls: plastic ware, clothing and shoes, children’s toys, computer parts, henna “tattoos” and hair-braiding.



Noisy and hectic street market in Zanzibar
  

In 1967 a new gem was discovered near the foothills of Kilimanjaro. Tiffany &Co bought rights to mine it and bestowed upon it the name “Tanzanite”, as this is the only known place in the world where it is found. When cut and polished, Tanzanite becomes a kaleidoscope of royal blue, violet, indigo, lilac and periwinkle. It is 1000 times rarer than diamonds and earns the Tanzanian government $20 million dollars a year. So…what’s a girl to do?? I felt it my duty to assist the local economy and had soon adorned my pinkie with a small violet-blue chip - the perfect souvenir of a delightfully delicious weekend in Zanzibar!

 






The Muhimbili Compound

 


Hospital census frequently doubles as patients sleep in hallways wait for surgery
  It took almost a week before I could find my way around this very large health care area. It can best be described as a multi-building complex for many specialty units that are linked by a long and circuitous outdoor walkway, much like spokes on a wheel. You can “get on/off” thru the occasional openings. It is 6’ wide and covered for protection from the rains. It is much too narrow for the masses of ill and barely ambulatory patients and vast number of visitors that shuffle along from one clinic to another. One must also step aside for the food carts and medical supply wagons. It is a perfect macrocosm of downtown Dar! David worked in the Muhambili Orthopedic Hospital (MOI) with 300 “official” beds. This number almost doubles when you add in those who are lying on mattresses on the ward floors and in the hallways. I asked Patrick in Social Services for an accurate census. He said he didn’t know but would be happy to send a “helper” to go to the wards and count heads. (Nothing is computerized.) There are also rooms for “private patients” who have a medical plan with their employer, or an adequate income. These rooms may be singles, doubles or triples (depending on the insurance plan) with a shared bathroom and a small TV and they cost $15 a day. Doctors receive reimbursements for these private patient services, unlike in the public side of the hospital where 80% of the patients cannot pay. It is here that doctors earn enough money to support their families.
 

 Everyone has a mobile phone. The various ring tones erupting from pockets or purses are ubiquitous.  It is not considered rude to pick up a call at any moment or in any place; it is their only way to keep in touch since very few of the hospital departments have telephones or computers.

   In 2008 the government passed a law allowing motorcycles to transport passengers (essentially, taxi-“donor”-cycles). Since then the hospital patient census has increased by 67% due to the horrendous number and nature of crashes. They are building a new modern hospital close by and hope to move in within a year. Though the equipment will be the most advanced available, the biggest challenge will be the maintenance needed to keep
Bad news: This guy really shouldn't be hanging
around the operating room.
Good news: He probably ate up a lot of the flies
that had taken up residence there.
it running. Lights, computers, air conditioners are often non-functional, I’m not sure I saw a single clock that had anywhere near the correct time. All operating equipment is autoclaved which causes corrosion to many of these delicate instruments. And no one knows how to fix this stuff! It is very frustrating to see donated equipment worth many thousands of dollars to be ware-housed in a back room, and now missing dials or buttons or handles which had been pilfered and repurposed for home use or some other nonsense.

   Due to the lack of certain sophisticated equipment, Tanzania has contracted with the Apollo group of hospitals in India, which offers state-of-the-art surgery for certain brain surgeries, and has excellent results. It must be certified by 3 physicians that such treatment is not available in Tanzania before the patient can be put on a lengthy waiting list. This poses the question: How can Tanzania 
The new hospital expected to open
 by the end of 2014
advance in its health care delivery if it does not have the opportunity to learn to do these surgeries in it’s own country? The new seven storied hospital being built, adjacent to the present one, has so far cost $11 million and will have 380 beds. It is envisioned to be Tanzania's surgical "tour de force". We have little doubt it will be magnificent; the question is: Will its high caliber of proficiency be maintained in a year or 2, or will the equipment break down, and staff revert to its previous inefficiency. It’s a head-scratcher but the answer will present itself soon enough.

 

 





Nursing Care

 
   After being a hospital nurse for 30 years (Ye gawds!!), you never get it out of your system, even with retirement. I have always been anxious to learn more and Tanzania proved a fascinating place for comparison.

    I chose to visit the combined neuro (125 beds)/orthopedic (320 beds) wards. These beds are always full and the number of patients almost doubles when you add the mattresses on the floor between the beds and in the hallways. The AM nursing shift starts with vital signs but only for those patients who “appear sick”. When I 
Nurses station on the 66 bed neuro/ortho ward
approached the open nursing station in the mid-section of the ward, I was surprised to see all staff members relaxing in chairs and joking with each other. There are no call lights and the patients require little care as the families do the bathing, feeding and ambulating. In fact, many of these patients are quite healthy, and have only “moved in” as they await surgery. They may well be living here 2-3 months and by occupying a mattress, they are assured not to ”lose their place in line”. All surgeries are the same price: $140 and patients must pay at least half of that ahead of time in order to have their operation. Often the patients just live there as their families organize enough money to make the payment, or until they move up on the OR schedule. They want to be ready whenever the doctor is. Nurses with a 4 year degree earn 500,000 to 600,000 Tanz. shillings a month ($350-400) from which is taken 15% taxes, as well as insurance. Living costs in the surrounding hospital area are high, with typical rent for a moderately dilapidated 2 bedroom apt. from the 60’s-70’s renting for US$1400, and those of a barely higher quality going for $2000. While local fresh fruit is a bargain, remaining food stuffs are not; a pound of coffee: $8, a cup of yogurt or a pint of milk: $1.50, one dozen eggs: $3. and chicken is over double what we pay in the US.

 

 

NGO (Non-Government Organizations)

 

   This is humanitarian work in every field imaginable run by organizations which have no ties to any government. NGO’s must be independent of any political ideology and are often (though not always) funded by the private sector. They offer multi-faceted support to developing countries in  the fields of need such as literacy, agriculture, family-planning, sanitation, AIDS etc. It is impossible to overestimate their value as they effect change throughout Africa. No doubt, they are more ubiquitous than McDonalds and Starbucks combined, and though they have been criticized in the past for pushing their own values, they now operate under the buzzword: “sustainability”. This philosophical shift of mentorship has created the proliferation of offices and programs managed by local people, who in turn hire locals for outreach programs. They also focus on using only local services and goods for their operation.

  I spent a morning at the Ariel/Elizabeth Glaser Foundation. You may recall how Elizabeth Glaser captured headlines in the 1970’s when, 5 years after receiving a blood transfusion in childbirth, she was found to be HIV+, as were her 2 children. Her husband, Michael was a well-known actor from Starsky and Hutch as well as other movie roles. Elizabeth started the foundation and was an outspoken voice to this still “silent epidemic”, long before it became "acceptable" to speak out. Tragically, her daughter Ariel died at age 8 and Elizabeth died several years later. The foundation now has a
Elizabeth Glazer and Ariel / press photo
yearly operating budget of almost $122 million and has health centers around the world. It's African affiliates are in Tanzania, the Ivory Coast and Mozambique. The district office in Dar employs 20 and another 40 work in its outreach programs in rural areas. Speaking in their mother tongue of Swahili, local people are trained to run clinics, organize treatment regimens and foster close ties with remote communities. These African affiliates are run entirely by their own people and are therefore sustainable. That means that even if the NGO were to close and abandon its mission, its work could continue with minimal transition. NGO’s are unquestionably a win-win for all.

  David accompanied me when I spent an afternoon with USAID (United states Agency for International Development). Their headquarters are located in the US Embassy and since the bombing in 1998, the security is very, very tight. After multiple screenings, sign-ins and bullet-proof doors, we were finally admitted into the office of a director of the AIDS and literacy program. The goal is to empower local areas but there is a continuous problem with funds being “diverted” (we all know what that means-). To counteract this, all funding is now handled on what they call a “G.to G.” basis, that is “government to government”. We pressed to better understand how this avoids corruption; does it not just result in greater pays-off to the “higher ups”? The director had no explanation. USAID’s largest programs include Health, Education, Feed the Future and Democracy in Government. Tanzania receives $275 million from the US government and has seen a reduction of AIDS from a previous high of 8-12%, now down to 5% in some provinces. There is no shortage of work to be done.

 

 

Nursing School


Nursing school. Class of 2016
     
 

 After asking 3 clueless security guards where I could find the Nursing School, I finally stumbled on an old obscure building that appeared abandoned from the outside. The 4 year nursing program has just recently been shortened to 3 years in hopes of higher graduation rates. I sat in on 2 classes and was asked to speak about “Nursing in USA” as well as do a Q&A. The students complained that nursing is not considered a respected profession and they wanted to know more about employment opportunities in America. I responded that nurses in America are highly valued and that the mandatory nursing boards are very challenging for those not truly fluent in English. They also were very interested to know the different between hospital care in Tanzania vs. USA. With great diplomacy, I carefully crafted words to minimize the wide disparity. In the classes I attended, the teachers were highly didactic (rarely breaking their oratory except when their own cell phone would ring) and students would come and go at whim. There was no text, students wrote lecture notes in small notebooks, and the material itself was simple and of minimal importance. Interaction with the students was rare, and teachers did not know their names.

       Every Wednesday at 7:30AM was a weekly conference for nurses. It was almost 8AM before close to 40 charge and head nurses had gathered in the conference room. Nurse Violeth started her presentation by reading the power point slides that she had copied from an out-dated English nursing text. For the remaining 75% of her lecture, I was surprised and disappointed that she spoke only in Swahili. I didn’t mind that the power point material was boring, but its absurd simplicity troubled me (“Remember to respect the patient and his belongings”, “The health of the patient is our primary goal”, “Inform the patient of any planned treatments”, “Chart your actions and observations”). This might have been appropriate for new nursing students in their first week of class, but certainly not for seasoned nurses.  

Tara and David check on patients in ICU

 The hospital made a concerted effort several years ago to improve the quality of its ICU by sending 5 of their RN’s to South Africa for intense training. Paying for airfare, housing and wages, the plan was for them to return to Tanzania after 2 years and teach their co-workers the high level of care they are learned. Even though the cost savings would have been tremendous had they instead, imported one nurse from South Africa to come to Dar; the feeling was that only such intense “reprogramming” would change the ways of the Tanzanian nurses. The consensus is that this program is working, albeit slowly. There is some push-back, as expected, on the part of those nurses who stayed home. They really aren't too interested in change-

 

 

 

Nobody knows nuthin'

 

   A great frustration for us was trying to obtain simple information. The people are intelligent, kind and eager to help but seem to know only what is happening in their own small microcosm: a secretary on the first floor of the nursing building did not know that the administrator’s office was just one floor above; a security guard at one entrance of the hospital could not direct me to the other entrance, our taxi driver never heard of the American Embassy, We got lots of nods and smiles, everyone wanted to be congenial but no one seem to have answers to our simple questions. Another problem is “African Time” ie, late! The hotel kitchen staff often arrived late for breakfast set-up. Classes in schools started late, nurses arrived late for their shift, and restaurants took an inordinate amount of time to  fill even a small order. “Hakuna matata” (no worries) they would say if you showed any frustration, reminding you that the problem was yours and not theirs. It is just the way of their world, and required adjustment on our part.

 

The Three “R”s

 A law was passed in Tanzania that schools may no longer collect fees for children to attend. Unfortunately, many public schools continue to demand a “contribution” before the child will be enrolled; in effect, denying education to a large majority of Tanzanian children. Only 1 out of 3 kids start secondary school (grade 8) and of these, only 4 out of 100 will complete grade 12. Families often discourage education because they have no money to pay the “contribution” as well as uniforms, shoes, texts and school supplies, and “rent” toward a desk. For those parents earning just a few dollars a day, this is an impossibility, especially if they have more than one child. They also lose that child for work at home, or in the fields for 9 months of the year. Most schools are in a horrific state of decay with crumbling walls, minimal lighting and desks designed for 2 kids now crammed with 4. With rare exception, public schools do not have toilets, not even for the teachers. Of the few that do, there is no separate facility for girls.


8th graders at an all-girls school who were on break from classes.
They were anxious to learn about the American education system. I
I had brought yarn for "cat's cradle", which we all enjoyed. I also
handed out chapsticks to all the classes, a thoughtful donation
 from Costco Pharmacy Services.


 
As in Ethiopia, English is taught as a core class starting in 5th grade, but not spoken in the classroom until the start of secondary school, grade 8. Unfortunately, by then it is difficult to master the necessary nuances of proficiency and a heavy, hard-to-understand accent remains. Considering how few children actually continue on to high school, it makes for a country sorely lacking in verbal skills that are necessary for economic advancement in a modern world. It was often difficult to understand many professionals with whom we had conversations. Often David and I would look quizzically at each other, as if to ask: is this person speaking English or Swahili? We often couldn't tell until much of the conversation had been completed.We have received emails from several Tanzanian doctors since our return and find very basic spelling and grammar errors in each one.

 

 

Standard 5

 

 “Standard” is the old British word for grade level, and is commonly used throughout Africa. I had made appointments to visit a primnary school and a secondary all-girls school. Earlier that week I had spoken to Teacher Yacinta of the 5th grade primary school class and she welcomed my visit. She had shown me where I could find her. I poked my head in the door, expecting it to be her office and much to my surprise about 50 excited little kids jumped up and down in their seats and, speaking all together in a loud cadence, announced: “Welcome, Mara to Dar es Salaam, we are very happy to meet you!” And they certainly were, that was apparent! As was I…this was one of the warmest heart-felt welcomes I can recall, and I didn’t hesitate to tell them so. Their English was very basic but they eagerly participated in a simple geography game about the U.S. that I quickly invented. When responding to a teacher’s question, they are not allowed to speak until called upon. Instead, hands go flying high in the air and their fingers go snap! snap! snap as they all vie to be called upon. When chosen, they immediately stand at their desk and eagerly speak. They are joyous little learners and the teachers of this primary school age group seem to easily keep the class motivated. As I left, they blew me kisses and asked me to return the next day which was not possible. I was already scheduled to visit an orphanage and after that…back to the states. I made a 10 sec. video of their greeting to me, please take a look at it. Their happiness is infectious!

 

Kiwohede (KIota WOmens HEalth and DEvelopment org)


Lovely Edda, and I show off my new bracelet
   Since we were staying in our small hotel for 2 weeks, I got to know the staff and asked them for recommendations of interesting places to visit, and this was at the top of the list. Kiwohede is the Swahili word for “nest” and it was founded by Justa Mwaituka. She started this foundation after a trip to India 15 years ago, when she visited orphanages that also served as drop-in centers for girls at risk. Her foundation now has 22 such centers (“nests”) throughout Dar, each bustling with educational and vocational programs, health information, social activities and counseling. I arrived to the music of 45 boisterous and youthful voices singing African songs as they strung beads and created brightly colored necklaces and bracelets. Along the wall were over 20 sewing machines where tailoring was being taught, and there was a large area for making batik. These items were then sold in a small shop next to the center to earn  money for more materials.

     



                                                                                                                                        Justa introduced me to Edda who is the program director She was dressed in a beautiful batik dress, sewn by the students. As we toured the building she spoke of her biggest concern: the girls at risk on the streets. It is not unusual for girls to  be married very young, often just at puberty, and they are expelled from school when they become pregnant. There is often violence in these relationships and 1 out of 3 adolescents reports being beaten, choked, burned or attacked with a knife. If they flee, there is little left for them except prostitution, as their families will not take them back. There are over 2 million AIDS orphans in Tanzania. The production of sisal (used for rope) is a major export for the country, as is coffee, tea and sugarcane, and 1/3 of the labor force for harvesting these crops are children, ages 12-14 who do back-breaking labor for 11 hours daily. Clearly, there are lots of at-risk kids who can benefit from Justa’s vision.


Making beaded jewelry at Kiwahede. Notice the toothbrushes that
 I was able to give out, donated by my kind dentist, Dr. Lui in Bellevue.
   The Kiwohede Centers offer a retreat; a place to go for street kids to experience a more appropriate environment and make new friends, get health information, learn a vocation and even attend secondary school tuition-free. I enjoyed immensely my day there and was very impressed with all they do. I bought a lovely beaded bracelet as a souvenir and will send them our remaining Tanzanian shillings as a donation.



Saying good-by (Kwaheri)

 

Seeing the city in a Bajaji (aka tuk-tuks), air conditioned
 3 wheelers that zip thru traffic and drive on sidewalks.
  What a country of extremes is Tanzania (pronounced “Ten-ZEN-ya” by its inhabitants), as it is poised for major growth and technological advancement, yet still remains primitive and agrarian.Though most visitors have plans for a safari or to scale Mt. Kilimanjaro, our work kept us in Dar. Dar es Salaam actually means “abode of peace”, though perhaps not so much in this modern era as when they named it. The traffic is abominable, perhaps the very worst we had ever seen, and during rush hour (4-8PM) cars are often at a complete standstill, moving only a short distance every several minutes. The roads are a disaster with immense pot-
Typical pothole with broken pipe below ground
holes causing many drivers to just drive on the sidewalks or create their own roadway thru the shrubbery. Considering its metropolitan population of 2½ million people, it has barely more than a dozen stoplights, which are frequently ignored or just out of service. The cars have the steering wheel on the right and they drive on the opposite side of road, but the truth is they drive anywhere and everywhere and no one seems to stop them. As a pedestrian, one must be very, very vigilant. It is clear there is good reason to worry since we usually saw morning reports on 20-25 patients that had come into the emergency room with mangled arms and legs and brains. Young adults and children are not spared by the fast and wild drivers who don't limit their hellish driving to the nighttime.

   The Tanzanian people are good and kind. They love their babies, and they care for their elderly. In the morning as we walked to the hospital, women gathered along the roadside brewing rich dark African coffee on small piles of charcoal or they grilled fresh chapati to sell to passers-by. I don’t know where they sleep, no doubt some small hovel not far away, but they never hesitate to say “good morning” to everyone they see. Poverty does not undermine their cheerfulness. This is the camaraderie of the street and their fundamental good nature.


Downtown Dar as seen from our catamaran. New sky scrapers
are appearing everywhere
Downtown open market where all major produce is sold
  There is a total of 6 neurosurgeons in all of Tanzania serving a population of 45 million inhabitants. It is a country rich with minerals and resources but much too little is spent on infrastructure, health care, and education. Dar is the 3rd fastest growing city in Africa and building cranes populate the skyline. The many skyscrapers going up on every available empty lot are being built by businessmen from India and China; few are from Tanzania. As frequently seen in African nations, economic development has a parasitic relationship with many of its developers. But who can fault it; even with 2 steps back and one step forward, there is still that one small forward step that otherwise would not be.

   As I walk to the hospital from our hotel, I think of the basics I have come to expect: running water for a shower, a healthy meal, a safe place to sleep, a chance to realize my dreams, and I am overwhelmed by such a rich bounty. I see a young fellow on the street, perhaps 12 or 14 years old, hauling a heavy wooden cart laden down with sweet pineapples, mangoes and papaya. The handles are yoked over his shoulders and he sweats in the humid heat. I wonder what he thinks. Does he wish he were in school? Does he ask himself if he will he be able he to pull this cart for the next 40 years? Has he given up on his dreams, or did he never have any? Is it already too late?


"Tinga-Tinga" is a well known folk
art style from the 60's, created by Edward
Tingatinga, a Tanzanian. David thought we didn't
have room for any of his artwork, but
 I found a perfect spot!
 
   I have come to realize Tanzania will never catch up, nor will any other country in sub-Saharan Africa. There is no broad stroke of a paintbrush that will brighten the shadows; there just isn't time. Eventually new equipment will be in the hospitals, wider roads in the cities and the first generation of tech-savvy programmers will connect with cyberspace. But by then, the rest of the modern world will be even further advanced, leaving in its wake this nation that coulda, woulda, shoulda…but didn’t. I’m so sorry, Tanzania, there is so much of you and so little of me to make any difference whatsoever, but of course, I knew that before I came. You are like a sweet little lagging toddler who just needs to keep taking those steps forward, as best you can-

   We fly home, 9 hours from Dar to Amsterdam then almost 10 to Seattle. We sleep, read, and watch movies. My home feels so good to me. I put my head on my pillow and drift off into sweet Tinga-tinga dreams about Africa.
Ahhh...hakuna matata...